Places to order pie online

-Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission.

Pi Day is coming up on March 14—you know, because 3.14—and even if you’re not a huge fan of mathematics, you still might want to celebrate, if only because it’s an excuse to eat pie!

There’s more where this deal came from. Sign up for Reviewed’s Perks and Rec newsletter and we’ll keep ’em coming every Sunday through Friday.

People typically celebrate this holiday by chopping down on their favorite type of pie, whether it’s apple, pecan, strawberry rhubarb, key lime, or something in between, and if you’re not in the mood to whip out your pie dishes and bake, we have great news for you: There are quite a few bakeries that allow you to order pie online, and they’ll ship the freshly baked treat right to your door.

Here are 10 of our favorite options for Pi Day.


We love Goldbelly, so If you haven’t heard of the site, prepare to have your mind blown. This unique marketplace is your one-stop-shop for all things food, as it allows you to order all types of cuisine from restaurants around the country. And yes, that includes lots of pies!

Through Goldbelly, you can order a freshly made pie from Four & Twenty Blackbirds in New York, Two Fat Cats Bakery in Maine, or Blue Owl Bakery in Missouri, and it will arrive at your doorstep in a matter of days. Thanks to Goldbelly’s wide selection of restaurants and bakeries, they have virtually every type of pie imaginable, including classics, savory pies, and even mini pies to share with friends.

Shop pies from Goldbelly

2. Harry & David

These treats are available with two-day shipping.

Harry & David is best-known (and Reviewed-approved) for its gift baskets, but the brand also has a decent selection of gourmet pies that you can order online. They have options like classic cherry pie, American-style apple pie, key lime pie, and chocolate cream pie, and most of their desserts come with two-day shipping, so you’ll be choosing down before you know it. Just keep in mind that orders placed after 1 pm EST on Wednesdays ship out the following Monday to avoid getting delayed over the weekend.

Shop pies from Harry & David

Cheaper gas: Sam’s Club memberships are virtually free right now—save on gas, appliances, pantry staples and more

►Will soaring gas prices put your job at risk? These occupations may feel the heat

3. Milk Bar

Milk Bar only offers one type of pie, but it's still an unbeatable choice.

It’s no secret that we love Milk Bar, so it brings us great pleasure to tell you that this iconic bakery does, in fact, offer a pie. Admittedly, you only have one option—the Milk Bar Pie—but it won’t disappoint on Pi Day. The treat has a buttery, salty-sweet filling inside a hearty oat-cookie crust, and it serves eight to 10 people, so be sure to invite a few friends. The pie will be delivered right to your door, and you can easily add-on other Milk Bar goodies, like a pack of cookies or cake truffles.

Get the Milk Bar Pie from Milk Bar for $49

4. Williams Sonoma

William Sonoma offers a variety of frozen pies from bakeries around the country.

5. Bake Me A Wish

These pies come with next day shipping, and you can even choose a Pi Day gift box!

Bake Me A Wish makes it easy to ship all sorts of delicious desserts, and they have a truly impressive selection of pies for Pi Day. They have classics like apple and blueberry pie, as well as more unique options, such as sour cherry. There are even a few savory options if you’re not into sweets! The pies ship via next-day delivery, and the brand even has a special Pi Day gift box that you can choose—ideal if you’re shipping the treat to a loved one.

Shop pies from Bake Me A Wish

6. Grand Traverse Pie Company

There are dozens of shippable pies to choose from—good luck picking just one!

When it comes to selection, it’s hard to beat Grand Traverse Pie Company, which ships its treats from Michigan. They have dozens of pies to choose from, including fruit pies like apple, cherry, mixed berry, peach, and blueberry, as well as cream pies. There are even gluten-free options and 6-inch mini pies that come in a pack of three. The company ships its pies four days a week, and you can order a second pie for no additional shipping fee—so go ahead, get two!

Shop pies from Grand Traverse Pie Company

7. Three Brothers Bakery

Three Brothers, which is based in Texas, makes delicious pecan pies in several flavors.

8. Chocolate Maven

You'll find unique pie flavors, such as this apple cranberry.

For those with dietary restrictions, most of Chocolate Maven’s delicious pies can be made gluten-free, and select options can be made vegan! The Santa Fe-based bakery offers an impressive selection of pies that can be shipped nationwide, including unique options like blackberry, cranberry apple, and chocolate cherry, and at checkout, you can select whether you want a gluten-free or vegan crust.

Shop pies from Chocolate Maven

9. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Peanut buttercream pie?  I'll take two!

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has locations around the country, but if you’re not within driving distance, you can get many of their signature pies delivered right to your door. Choose from their Chewy Chocolate Chip Pie, Peanut Butter Cream Pie, or special I-40 Pie, which contains pecans, chocolate chips, and a sprinkle of toasted coconut—plus plenty of other options. There are even pie and cookie bundles!

Can’t decide which one sounds the best? Buttermilk Sky offers a Mini Pie Collection that comes with eight 4-inch miniature pies, including two each of their Caramel Turtle, Pecan, Chewy Chocolate Chip, and signature I-40 treats.

Shop pies from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

10. PieGram

PieGrams are the best kind of mail!

What better way to let someone know you’re thinking about them than with a PieGram? These packages contain miniature 6-inch pies that are handmade in Wisconsin, and you can choose from four flavors—cherry crumb, apple crumb, chocolate pecan, and strawberry rhubarb. You can order a single, double, or quadruple PieGram, and there are cute pie-themed cards that you can include with your order for no additional fee.

The product experts at Reviewed have all your shopping needs covered. Follow Reviewed on Facebook, Twitter, instagram, TikTokgold Flipboard for the latest deals, product reviews, and more.

Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

Leave a Comment