I Compared Martha Stewart and Ina Garten’s BLT Sandwiches

Martha Stewart and Ina Garten both have a large repertoire of recipes, including recipes for BLTs.

Martha Stewart and Ina Garten both have recipes for BLTs.

Erin McDowell/Insider; Noam Galai/WireImage/Getty Images; Christopher Polk/Getty Images


I decided to try both of the celebrity chefs’ recipes in order to determine which one I preferred. Unsurprisingly, both recipes called for similar ingredients, but there were a few differences between Garten’s and Stewart’s methods for making a BLT.

Martha Stewart opts for homemade mayonnaise to make her “perfect” BLT, while Garten uses avocado in her California-inspired sandwich. I made them both to find which one would be my new go-to lunch.

Ina Garten’s California BLT recipe calls for smoked bacon, tomato, large lettuce leaves, an avocado, a lemon, white bread, and “good mayonnaise.”

ingredients for ina garden blt

The ingredients for Ina Garten’s BLT.

Erin McDowell/Insider


Garten recommends using Hellmann’s, which is the brand I already buy and can be found in practically every grocery store.

I usually fry my bacon, but the recipe said to bake it, and I really liked this method.

trader joes apple smoked bacon on a sheet pan

The bacon slices on a wired sheet pan.

Erin McDowell/Insider


The recipe calls for enough smoked bacon to make two sandwiches, but I cut the recipe in half to make just enough for myself.

I preheated the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. I placed five strips of bacon on a baking wire rack on a sheet pan and put it in the heated oven. After 20 minutes in the oven, the bacon turned out perfectly crispy.

The strips of bacon were a little on the thinner side, but I didn’t mind that. Cooking the bacon on the wire rack was easier than frying it, in my opinion. There was no flipping required and each side turned out perfectly crisp.

I toasted the bread in the preheated oven for about five minutes, flipped them, and toasted them for another minute.

two slices of bread with mayonnaise

Two slices of bread with mayonnaise.

Erin McDowell/Insider


I then smeared about a tablespoon of Hellmann’s regular mayonnaise onto each slice.

I then added washed and dried butter lettuce leaves to each side of the sandwich.

lettuce on two slices of bread

Lettuce on two slices of bread.

Erin McDowell/Insider


I ended up using about five lettuce leaves.

I then peeled and sliced ​​the avocado before adding it to a small bowl.

avocado slices with lemon

Avocado slices in a bowl with lemon.

Erin McDowell/Insider


I sliced ​​a lemon in half and squeezed the juice on top of the avocado slices, lightly tossing them. You don’t want to mash or mix the avocado slices too vigorously, just enough to coat them in the lemon juice.

I added the avocado slices and bacon on top of the sandwich. There was a perfect amount of bacon to ensure that I would get an even bite.

lettuce avocado and bacon on two slices of bread

Lettuce, avocado, and bacon on two slices of bread.

Erin McDowell/Insider


Before adding the bacon to the sandwich, I soaked up some of the excess oil with a paper towel.

I then added four slices of tomato and seasoned it liberally with salt and pepper.

lettuce tomato avocado and bacon on two slices of bread

Lettuce, avocado, tomato, and bacon on two slices of bread.

Erin McDowell/Insider


Other than the bacon, the other ingredients took no time at all to prepare.

The sandwich was really easy to make and required minimal effort and cleanup.

finished in a garten blt

The finished BLT.

Erin McDowell/Insider


The avocado added a creamy element to the sandwich, and the lemon juice really enhanced its flavor. It tasted fresh and was perfect for a spring or summer lunch. The seasoned tomato slices also perfectly complemented the crispy bacon, which had a slightly sweet flavor.

While the simple recipe initially seemed like a no-brainer, the addition of lemon juice took it over the top and made it really stand out. I also loved the method of baking the bacon — while it took longer to make, I didn’t have to stand around flipping the bacon to ensure it was getting crispy on both sides.

I was excited to see how Martha Stewart’s BLT recipe would measure up.

Martha Stewart’s recipe for a “perfect” BLT uses thick-cut bacon, tomato, and lettuce. I opted for romaine, but you can use any kind you prefer.

martha stewart blt

The ingredients for Martha Stewart’s BLT.

Erin McDowell/Insider


For Martha Stewart’s “perfect BLT” sandwich, you’ll need white sandwich bread, a vine-ripe tomato, two lettuce leaves, a slice of thick-cut bacon, basil, butter, salt, pepper, and homemade mayonnaise.

The first thing I noticed about Stewart’s BLT recipe was that it calls for homemade mayonnaise, which I’ve never made before.

martha stewart blt

I whisked my mayonnaise, but you can also use a blender.

Erin McDowell/Insider


For Stewart’s homemade mayo, you’ll need one large egg yolk, one teaspoon of Dijon mustard, one teaspoon of fresh lemon juice, coarse salt, white pepper — I substituted it with black pepper, as it’s what I had — and a cup of lightly flavored oil.

Stewart’s recipe called for grapeseed, sunflower, or safflower oil, but I used vegetable oil — which is also mild in flavor — because I already had it in my kitchen.

The first step in making homemade mayo is mixing together the egg yolk, Dijon mustard, salt, pepper, and lemon juice.

My finished mayonnaise didn’t exactly look like the store-bought Hellman’s mayo I usually buy, but at least it was spreadable.

martha stewart blt

My finished mayonnaise.

Erin McDowell/Insider


The key to making the homemade mayonnaise was slowly adding in the oil.

You really need to add the oil drop by drop, or else your mayonnaise won’t thicken. Then, when you’re halfway through your oil, gently pour the rest of it into your bowl in a slow, steady stream while mixing.

I was proud that I was able to make something remotely close to mayonnaise on my own. I also made more than I expected to use in the sandwich.

I fried up some thick-cut maple brown sugar bacon in a pan on the stove.

martha stewart blt

The bacon I used in the BLT.

Erin McDowell/Insider


I found that this slightly sweeter cut caramelizes nicely in the pan and adds a delicious element to savory dishes. The recipe only calls for one slice of bacon, compared to Garten’s which calls for three slices per sandwich. However, you could undoubtedly add more if you want a more filling lunch.

I fried the bacon, which took far less time than baking it. However, I preferred the crispy texture and result I got with Garten’s method.

Martha Stewart’s recipe is interesting in that it calls for both butter and homemade mayonnaise.

martha stewart blt

The toasted bread slices spread with butter and mayonnaise.

Erin McDowell/Insider


I’ve never added butter to a BLT sandwich before, so I was interested to see how it would taste.

I was also anxious to see how the homemade mayonnaise would fare. Out of curiosity, I tried a little on a spoon and found that while it didn’t exactly taste like the mayo I was used to, it had a nice citrusy flavor from the lemon juice.

Martha Stewart’s BLT didn’t taste like any other BLT I’ve ever had, largely due to the homemade mayonnaise and basil.

martha stewart blt

My finished BLT sandwich.

Erin McDowell/Insider


The ingredients tasted really fresh and light, despite it being a bacon-based sandwich. The basil cut through the savory flavors perfectly, while the mayonnaise added a citrus flavor to the sandwich.

The vine-ripe tomatoes were also perfectly sweet, juicy, and flavorful. Altogether, the sandwich tasted similar to an Italian Caprese salad, plus bacon.

However, I definitely preferred the butter lettuce I used in Garten’s sandwich over the romaine, and I even preferred the store-bought mayonnaise over my first attempt at a homemade version.

Leave a Comment